For two years we’ve seen and heard it everywhere. 81% of white evangelicals voters chose to cast their vote for Donald Trump. Recently, my colleagues Ed Stetzer and Andrew MacDonald, in partnership with LifeWay Research, conducted a survey they felt ultimately debunked—or helped contextualize—the 81% myth. They pointed to six key factors in evangelical voters’ approach to the 2016 election that might help differentiate between those identifying as evangelical and those holding evangelical beliefs.
The gist of their findings: There are several nuanced issues among evangelicals by belief that led them to vote for Trump. Understanding those nuances might help soften the perceived blow that accompanies looking at voting trends in the 2016 election.
Unenthusiastic and Apathetic?
One surprising datapoint from the research found that many evangelicals proverbially held their noses while voting for Trump, unenthusiastic about him as a candidate. For many, it was less about casting a vote for Trump and more about casting a vote against Hillary Clinton. Seeing these votes as begrudging ballots helps contextualized the number of white evangelical voters who voted for Trump. In that way, the data is beneficial.
While the data tells one story, I’m worried about the perception of apathy surrounding some of the President’s actions. In some instances, it’s more than a perception of indifference—it’s outright defense. Some are dumbfounded by a level of apathy or defense for issues that seem ripe for critique from the Christian community.
It’s hard to process data that says many evangelicals were unenthusiastic about Trump as a candidate when some apathetically ignore some of his words and actions as the President. I’m not talking about Supreme Court nominations, the economy, and other issues the study also found were important to evangelicals. I’m talking about things that Christians should hold out as important matters—like honesty, character, and integrity.
If so many evangelicals held their noses voting from Trump why is it so difficult for some to criticize the President when he says or does something that doesn’t align with their worldview—or embodies common human decency? Why is it hard to call a lie a lie, even when it comes from the West Wing? Why is it, as Ed and Andrew point out, we’ve lowered the bar over the years on character in a political leader’s personal life?
For Black, Character Still Very Important
One group increasingly asking this question is African-American Christians. Trump has a 3% approval rating in the African-American community as a whole. This hardly fits the narrative that black unemployment falling to record lows makes him an endearing figure among African-Americans.
They have seen the tweets and heard the statements. Low IQ. Crazy. Unhinged. Dog. Crime loving. Disrespectful. These are just a few of the descriptive terms President Trump has used to describe Black men and women throughout his presidency.
Before becoming the commander in chief, the Department of Justice sued Trump’s organization for discrimination against African-Americans in renting practices. Trump also took out a full-page ad in four New York City newspapers calling for the death penalty for the Central Park Five—five minorities accused of raping a jogger in Central Park. Even after the perpetrator confessed to the crime and the men were exonerated, Trump maintained that their convictions should never have been vacated.
These kind of statements and actions are character issues. But according to the study’s data, not many White evangelicals are disturbed by President Trump’s comments about minorities.
When asked whether they agreed with the statement: “I am disturbed by comments President Trump has made about minorities,” 55% of evangelicals by belief agreed. Interestingly, when broken down by race the numbers tell a different story. 82% of African-Americans who are evangelical by belief agree with the statement, while only 42% of Whites who are evangelical by belief agree with the statement. Why such a disparity? What does this mean?
Moving the Bar
Here’s the disconnect—I think. When asked about the single most important reason they voted for their candidate, African-American evangelicals by belief thought that personal character was the fourth most important factor. On the other hand, White evangelicals by belief did not find it as important as five other key issues, including abortion and likely Supreme Court nominees.
While white evangelicals by belief overall have moved the bar on the importance of the personal life of political leaders, African-American evangelicals by belief have held their ground on the importance of character for political leaders.
I fear that moving the bar has lowered the bar when it comes to race relations among Christians. If what Ed and Andrew say is true and “many evangelicals voted for Trump for the future while overlooking the present,” then I fear evangelicals have risked years of processing past racial trauma for a future devoid of Black voices among them.
While campaigning, Trump asked Black voters one simple question: “What do you have to lose (supporting me)?” I believe the clear, resounding question among many African-American Christians who are evangelical by belief is simple: “Our dignity.”